Club Sim vs 3HK HaHaSIM (2026): Which Hong Kong SIM Should Developers Pick?

Short answer: most people should get HaHaSIM. Keeping it costs HK$10 a year, and the HK$50 preloaded balance covers five years. Club Sim used to cost HK$6 a year, but that SMS bundle is no longer on sale in 2026. It now costs about HK$15 a year, so it mainly suits people who already have one.

Last updated: 2026-11-05
View giffgaff SIMsarrow_forward
On this page
  1. 1. Background: Both Come from Major Carriers
  2. 2. Side-by-Side Comparison
  3. 3. Apps and Payments: Two Different Models
  4. 4. Why Get Your UK/US Backup SIM from LarkSIM
  5. 5. Which One? A Straight Answer for Each User
  6. 6. Bottom Line
  7. 7. Frequently Asked Questions
  8. 8. Related guides

Both SIMs receive SMS for free in mainland China, and both can be registered online with a Chinese passport or Exit-Entry Permit. The differences come down to how you pay and how the app works.

Plenty of people agonise over this and end up buying both. Check the table below and you'll have your answer in a minute.

A Hong Kong SIM covers HK banking and everyday verification. If you also need a number for services that don't support Hong Kong, like OpenAI and Claude, LarkSIM's giffgaff physical SIM and US T-Mobile physical SIM ship from stock in mainland China as factory-new official cards, and the US plan renews with WeChat Pay or Alipay.

Prices are as of November 2026. The carrier apps have the final price.

Background: Both Come from Major Carriers

Both cards are run by major Hong Kong carriers with their own networks, not small MVNOs reselling capacity:

  • check_circleClub Sim (HKT): owned by PCCW/HKT, which also owns CSL. The app targets younger users, and everything is sold as add-on bundles.
  • check_circleHaHaSIM (3HK × Fortress): a co-brand between Hutchison's 3HK and the electronics chain Fortress, aimed at travel and long-term roaming. It has lots of retail locations and wide roaming coverage.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureHKT Club Sim3HK HaHaSIMVerdict
Initial balanceHK$0 (bare SIM, buy add-ons)HK$50 (ready to use)HaHaSIM: no need to add a payment method right away
Incoming SMS in mainland ChinaFreeFreeTie: verification codes cost nothing
Yearly keep-alive costabout HK$15 (≈ ¥14)HK$10 (≈ ¥9)HaHaSIM: with the HK$6 bundle gone, Club Sim now costs more
How to keep it aliveBuy the Asia data roaming pass in the appBuy a 1-day China–HK–Macau roaming pack in the appTie: about a minute either way
How long the starting balance lastsNo starting balanceHK$50 covers 5 renewalsHaHaSIM: no top-ups for 5 years
Mainland roaming partnersChina Mobile / China Unicom (auto)China Unicom / China Mobile (auto)Tie: both use major mainland networks
Travel roaming day passes~HK$15/day (main APAC destinations)~HK$10–15/dayHaHaSIM slightly better: more flexible tiers
Accepted IDs for online KYCChinese passport, EEPChinese passport, EEPTie: both done online in ~5 minutes
Prices as of November 2026, per each carrier's app.

Apps and Payments: Two Different Models

If you'll use the card from the mainland long-term, how the app works and whether you can pay easily matter more than the few-dollar price gap.

Club Sim: everything is a bundle

There's no balance on the card. Everything is an add-on bundle, so keeping the number alive means buying one bundle in the app each year. The HK$6 SMS bundle people used to buy is reported as no longer on sale in 2026. The cheapest option now is the Asia data roaming pass at about HK$15.

It takes Visa/Mastercard and e-wallets. Check the checkout page for what's currently accepted. A card that can pay in foreign currency is the safest bet.

HaHaSIM: a classic prepaid balance

The card comes with HK$50, and each HK$10 day pass is deducted from it, so you don't need to keep adding a payment method.

Once the balance runs out after five years, top up with a card or e-wallet the app accepts.

Why Get Your UK/US Backup SIM from LarkSIM

Buy these Hong Kong SIMs from official channels or proper retailers. We don't sell them. We sell the other half: UK and US numbers for AI tools and overseas SaaS.

International mail takes three or four weeks, and second-hand cards come with an unknown history. Here's how we fix both:

  • check_circleShipped from stock in mainland China, dispatched within 24 hours of payment. No waiting weeks for international mail.
  • check_circleFactory-new official cards: never activated, never resold.
  • check_circleNo foreign bank card needed to renew: our support team tops up the US plan and you pay in RMB with WeChat Pay or Alipay. giffgaff credit can be added with official £10 top-up vouchers.

Pick the one you need:

  • check_circlegiffgaff physical SIM: a UK number for ¥99. One paid action every 6 months keeps it from being closed for inactivity. giffgaff has disconnected some numbers used long-term abroad, though, so keep only a small balance on it.
  • check_circleUS T-Mobile physical SIM: a real US +1 number, ¥199 including the first month. Wi-Fi Calling works on China-model iPhones, so you can receive codes over Wi-Fi in mainland China (the first activation needs an overseas network connection). Numbers are assigned at random, may have been used before and can't be swapped, and cards can't be returned once shipped.

Prices as of November 2026; see the product pages for current prices.

Which One? A Straight Answer for Each User

  • check_circleGet HaHaSIM: your first Hong Kong SIM, and you don't want to deal with payment methods. HK$50 covers five years of keep-alive, and it works as soon as you register.
  • check_circleGet Club Sim: you already have one and like paying for bundles in the app. It now costs about HK$15 (≈ ¥14) a year, a little more than HaHaSIM, and buying bundles in the app is painless.
  • check_circleEither works: opening HK bank accounts (HSBC / BOC HK / ZA Bank) and free verification in mainland China. If it's registered to you, there's no difference for receiving codes.

Bottom Line

Buying new? HaHaSIM is cheaper and easier. Already have Club Sim? Keep it. Don't overthink it.

Once your Hong Kong number is sorted, if you also need a UK or US number for AI tools and overseas SaaS, LarkSIM's giffgaff physical SIM and US T-Mobile physical SIM ship from stock in mainland China as factory-new official cards, and the US plan renews with WeChat Pay or Alipay.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there any SMS delay in mainland China?expand_more
Normally no. Both roam directly on China Mobile or China Unicom, so codes from HK banks, Google and Telegram usually arrive within seconds.
Can I renew Club Sim without a foreign credit card?expand_more
It depends on what the app's checkout accepts at the time. If an e-wallet works, use it. If not, HaHaSIM's preloaded balance is friendlier for people without a foreign card.
Can I use HaHaSIM's HK$50 for data?expand_more
Yes. When you travel to Hong Kong, Macau or abroad, buy a roaming data pack with the balance and you're online when you land. Just remember that eats into the balance you'd otherwise use for keep-alive.
If I forget to renew, which one is easier to recover?expand_more
Both usually give about 30 days of grace after expiry, and buying a pack in the app restores the number. After that it's cancelled and reissued to someone else.

Real UK +44 number · Ships from China · Chinese setup guides

giffgaff UK physical SIM

Register and manage a real UK mobile number yourself, shipped from local stock in China. The self-service SIM suits people who already have a way to top up; the worry-free SIM includes an official £10 top-up voucher.